What Ifs Chords

Decoding "What If" Chords: Expanding Musical Possibilities

"What if" chords, also known as secondary dominants or borrowed chords, are a powerful tool in music composition and improvisation. They aren't technically "new" chords, but rather existing chords used in unexpected ways to create harmonic interest and movement. This article will explore the concept of "what if" chords, explaining their function, application, and the creative possibilities they unlock.

Understanding the Basics: Chord Function and Roman Numeral Analysis

Before diving into "what if" chords, it's crucial to understand basic chord function within a key. Roman numeral analysis provides a framework for this. In a major key, I represents the tonic (the home chord), IV is the subdominant, and V is the dominant. These chords have specific roles in establishing tonality and creating harmonic progression. The dominant (V) naturally leads strongly to the tonic (I).

Introducing the "What If": Borrowing from Parallel Keys

The core idea behind "what if" chords lies in borrowing chords from closely related keys. The most common scenario involves borrowing the dominant chord (V) from the parallel minor key. For example, in the key of C major, the parallel minor is C minor. The dominant chord in C minor is G diminished (Gdim). Applying a "what if" approach, we might ask: "What if we used the V chord from C minor (Gdim) within our C major progression?" This creates a powerful, unexpected twist. The Gdim leads back strongly to C major, adding harmonic intrigue.

The "What If" Scenario: Secondary Dominants

This technique is frequently used with secondary dominants. A secondary dominant is the V chord leading not to the tonic of the current key, but to another chord within the key. For instance, in C major, if we want to strongly emphasize the IV chord (F major), we could use the dominant of F major (C major) as a secondary dominant. The progression might look like this: Am - G - C - F. Introducing C major before F major creates a stronger, more decisive movement towards F. The "what if" here is: "What if we prepped the IV chord with its dominant?"

Beyond the Dominant: Exploring Other "What If" Possibilities

While secondary dominants are the most frequent use of "what if" chords, the principle can be applied more broadly. We can ask "what if" about any chord in a key. For example:

Borrowing from the relative minor: In C major, the relative minor is A minor. We could borrow chords from A minor, adding a melancholic flavor to the C major progression.
Borrowing from other closely related keys: While less common, borrowing chords from keys a third or even a fifth away can produce interesting results, especially in more advanced compositions. However, it requires careful consideration of voice leading and overall harmonic coherence.

Practical Application: Composition and Improvisation

"What If" chords significantly impact both composition and improvisation. In composition, they add harmonic color and unexpected turns, making the piece more dynamic and interesting. In improvisation, they offer a wealth of possibilities for creating unique and engaging solos. By strategically inserting "what if" chords, improvisers can navigate unexpected harmonic territories, expanding their musical vocabulary and captivating the listener.

Voice Leading and Smooth Transitions: Avoiding Dissonance

While "what if" chords offer significant creative potential, it's crucial to manage voice leading effectively to prevent jarring dissonance. Smooth transitions between the "what if" chord and its resolution are essential for maintaining a pleasing and coherent harmonic flow. This often involves careful consideration of chord inversions and stepwise movement of individual voices.

Summary

"What if" chords, primarily employing secondary dominants and borrowed chords from related keys, add a layer of complexity and expressive power to music. They enable composers and improvisers to create engaging harmonic progressions and unexpected turns, expanding the possibilities within a given key. Mastering this technique involves understanding chord function, utilizing Roman numeral analysis, and carefully managing voice leading to ensure smooth transitions.

FAQs

1. What is the difference between a secondary dominant and a borrowed chord? A secondary dominant is a V chord leading to a chord other than the tonic of the current key. A borrowed chord is a chord taken from a related key, regardless of its function within that key. A secondary dominant is a type of borrowed chord.

2. Can I use "what if" chords in any style of music? Yes, "what if" chords can be used across various musical genres, although their application and frequency may vary. They are prevalent in jazz, classical, and even pop music, adding depth and richness to compositions.

3. How do I choose which "what if" chord to use? The choice depends on the desired harmonic effect and the overall context of the piece. Consider the emotional tone, the preceding and following chords, and the overall harmonic direction.

4. Are there any rules to follow when using "what if" chords? While there are no strict rules, prioritize smooth voice leading and avoid harsh dissonances. Consider the overall context and ensure the "what if" chord enhances rather than disrupts the musical flow.

5. How can I practice using "what if" chords? Start by experimenting with secondary dominants in simple progressions. Gradually incorporate borrowed chords from relative minor and parallel keys. Analyze existing music to identify how composers have used these chords effectively. Improvise over chord progressions, incorporating "what if" chords to create unique harmonic variations.

Search Results:

【Excel】IF函数与IFS函数的对比应用 - 知乎 与IF函数相比，IF函数的条件判断是层层递进的关系，IFS函数的条件判断是一种并列关系，如图7-3-4所示。提醒：虽然IFS函数的条件判断是一种并列关系，但是判断条件的排序，还是需要遵 …

Excel函数公式：多条件判断函数If、Ifs、Choose-百度经验 3 Dec 2018 · IF函数虽然简单好用，但是如果条件多了，写起来非常的麻烦，而且容易出错，后期也不好维护。如果嵌套次数超过3次，建议选用其他函数替代，例如IFS函数，或Choose函数。

excel中sumifs函数的使用方法 - 百度经验 14 Oct 2019 · 例2、多条件对某一类数据求总和如下表所示，表格统计了各个区域所有产品的销量，这里产品分很多型号，需要统计西北区域所有型号电视机销量求和，因为电视机分很多型 …

IF函数多个条件怎么用，if函数如何嵌套? - 百度经验 26 Mar 2019 · if函数是 Excel 中的条件判断函数，它由条件与两个返回结果组成，当条件成立时，返回真，否则返回假。if函数中的条件既可以单条件，也可以是多条件；多条件组合有三种 …

如何评价长沙IFS？ - 知乎 了解IFS，首先需要了解它的背景，IFS所在的芙蓉区东牌楼地块，为旧改拆迁土地，有111亩，是长沙五一商圈最后的大型地块，在整个长沙市中心也是极为罕见的，而这块地给谁，能否做 …

求大佬解答IFS和IFC区别，两者谁更强？ - 知乎 知乎，中文互联网高质量的问答社区和创作者聚集的原创内容平台，于 2011 年 1 月正式上线，以「让人们更好的分享知识、经验和见解，找到自己的解答」为品牌使命。知乎凭借认真、专业 …

Excel中的if和ifs函数如何使用？ - 百度经验 3 May 2019 · 接下来就是重点if函数的使用方法了。这里，咱们先来最简单的if，而不是ifs.判断年轻人还是中年人，设定大于30是中年，小于30是年轻人。

if函数，什么时候用嵌套，什么时候用ifs？ - 知乎 8 Feb 2022 · 这样IFS函数就输入了4个参数，而IF函数仅输入了3个参数，所以单条件判断，IFS函数不如IF函数简洁。多条件判断当然，以上并不能说明IFS函数不如IF函数。从office官方说 …

IFS内在家庭系统疗法 - 知乎 IFS内在家庭系统疗法有多火呢？这么说吧，Level 1的需要摇号才有机会获得培训资格。如果只能选一本书学习IFS，那么无疑是创始人所著的《部分心理学》。为了深化自己对IFS的理解， …

excel中ifs函数的使用-百度经验 16 Apr 2020 · ifs函数可以使用多个条件的条件函数，若满足某一条件，则会返回该条件的TRUE值。若存在多个条件，完全可以使用IFS来代替嵌套的if函数，不仅操作方便，而且阅读性还很好。