Self Evaluation Maintenance Model

The Self-Evaluation Maintenance (SEM) Model: Protecting Your Self-Esteem Through Social Comparison

We all strive for a positive self-image. Our self-esteem, that fundamental feeling of self-worth, is constantly shaped by our accomplishments, failures, and interactions with others. But what happens when someone close to us achieves something we also aspire to? Does their success boost our own spirits, or does it threaten our carefully constructed sense of self? The answer, according to the Self-Evaluation Maintenance (SEM) model, is nuanced and depends on several key factors. This model, developed by Abraham Tesser, provides a compelling framework for understanding how we manage our self-esteem in the context of our social relationships, specifically in situations involving social comparison.

Understanding the Core Principles of SEM

The SEM model posits that we protect our self-esteem by strategically managing our social comparisons. It hinges on three crucial elements:

Relevance: How relevant is the other person's achievement to your own self-concept? If your close friend excels in a field completely unrelated to your own aspirations (e.g., your friend becomes a renowned chef while you're a successful software engineer), the impact on your self-esteem is likely minimal. However, if their success directly relates to your own goals (e.g., both of you aspire to be published authors, and your friend gets a book deal first), the relevance is high, making the comparison more impactful.

Closeness: How close is your relationship to the other person? The closer the relationship (e.g., a sibling, best friend, or spouse), the greater the potential impact of their achievement on your self-esteem. This is because we tend to identify more strongly with those close to us, making their successes or failures feel more personal.

Performance: How well are you performing in the relevant domain? If you're already excelling in the area, your self-esteem is less vulnerable to the success of others. Conversely, if you are struggling, the success of a close friend or family member can be particularly threatening.

Reflection and Basking in Reflected Glory (BIRGing)

The SEM model suggests two primary strategies for managing self-esteem in the face of others' success:

Self-evaluation: This involves a direct comparison of your own performance to that of the other person. If the comparison is favorable, it boosts self-esteem. If unfavorable, it threatens it. This is where the relevance and performance components become critical. A poor performance in a highly relevant domain, when compared to a close friend's great success, can be devastating.

Reflection: This involves associating yourself with the other person's success, even if you haven't personally contributed to it. This is often referred to as "basking in reflected glory" (BIRGing). For instance, a sibling's academic achievement might be a source of pride for the entire family. BIRGing is a powerful strategy for boosting self-esteem when the comparison is unfavorable or the relevance is high, but you are not directly competing.

Example Scenarios Illustrating SEM

Consider these scenarios:

Scenario 1: The Competitive Brother

Two brothers, both aspiring basketball players, compete for the same college scholarship. One brother (Mark) excels, while the other (John) struggles. The relevance is high (both aspire to the same scholarship), the closeness is high (they are brothers), and John's performance is low. John is likely to experience a decline in self-esteem. He might engage in downward social comparison (comparing himself to less successful players) or distance himself from Mark.

Scenario 2: The Successful Cousin

A young woman's cousin becomes a renowned surgeon. While she herself is a successful accountant, the relevance is low (different career paths). Even though her cousin's achievement is significant, the impact on her self-esteem is likely minimal. She might even BIRG, feeling pride in her cousin's accomplishment.

Practical Implications and Managing Self-Esteem

Understanding SEM can help us manage our social comparisons more effectively. When faced with the success of others, we can:

Reassess relevance: Consider the actual relevance of the other person's achievement to your own goals and self-concept. If it's low, bask in their glory!
Focus on your own strengths: Remind yourself of your own accomplishments and focus on your own path to success.
Strengthen relationships: Maintain close relationships even when facing competitive situations. Support and celebrate others' achievements, recognizing that your self-worth isn't diminished by their success.
Seek mentorship or guidance: If you're struggling in a particular area, seek help to improve your performance.

Conclusion

The Self-Evaluation Maintenance model offers valuable insights into how we manage our self-esteem in social contexts. By understanding the interplay between relevance, closeness, performance, and the strategies of self-evaluation and reflection (BIRGing), we can navigate social comparisons more constructively. Recognizing that our self-worth is not contingent on others' achievements empowers us to build stronger relationships and cultivate a more resilient sense of self.

FAQs

1. Can SEM be applied to negative events? Yes, the SEM model can also explain how we react to the failures of others. If a close friend fails in a relevant domain, we may experience a boost in self-esteem (particularly if we're performing well) or engage in distancing to protect ourselves from the negative association.

2. Is BIRGing always a positive strategy? While BIRGing can boost self-esteem, excessive reliance on it can hinder personal growth and achievement. It's important to balance reflection with self-evaluation and personal striving.

3. How does self-handicapping relate to SEM? Self-handicapping (creating obstacles to one's own success) can be a defensive mechanism to protect self-esteem in anticipation of failure. It allows one to attribute poor performance to external factors rather than internal shortcomings, minimizing the threat to self-evaluation.

4. Does SEM apply to all types of social comparisons? While SEM primarily focuses on upward social comparison (comparing oneself to someone more successful), it also has implications for downward social comparison (comparing oneself to someone less successful).

5. Can I use SEM to improve my relationships? Absolutely. By understanding how others might be managing their self-esteem in relation to your achievements, you can be more mindful and supportive, fostering stronger and healthier relationships.

Search Results:

¿Para qué sirve Self y This en PHP? - Stack Overflow en español 10 Jan 2018 · quería saber el uso de estos dos y sus diferencias. He visto que tienen un uso parecido, pero lo que he visto no explican realmente cuál es mejor usar y por qué.

加载数据集的时候经常用到def __getitem__ (self, index):具体怎么理 … 5 Feb 2021 · 小白的一些理解： 1.如果这个 __getitem__ 方法在类dataset中定义，那么可以调用 __getitem__ 的方法就是必须要有 dataset [index]。并且因为这是magic方法，所以只要使用过 …

深度学习中，自监督 (self-supervised)和无监督 (unsupervised)有什 … 自监督学习（Self-supervised Learning），笼统而言，是对于“ 损失函数中使用到的监督信息无需人工标注 ”的训练范式的一种统称，自监督学习可以用在预训练上，也可以用在实际任务本身的训练 …

self–conscious意思_百度知道 self–conscious意思self-conscious是一个常见的英文表达，表示“自我意识强烈的、拘谨的、不自在的”，通常指一个人对自己的外貌、能力或行为感到不自在或害羞。self-conscious也可以用来形容 …

¿Para qué se utiliza self en POO en Python? 4 El parámetro self se refiere al objeto instanciado de esa clase sobre el cual se está invocando dicho método. Es decir, el objeto que usaste para llamar al método (en tu ejemplo persona1 y …

Self-Critique 提升大模型推理能力 21 Jan 2025 · 在上一篇文章 RFT（拒绝采样微调）：提升大模型推理能力中我们介绍了通过RFT提升大模型数学推理能力，这一篇文章我们将介绍另外一篇论文，也是使用了RFT，不同的是训练了 …

Self complementarity数值高好还是低好？_百度知道 21 Jul 2024 · Self complementarity数值高好还是低好？当涉及到Self-complementarity这一概念时，其数值的高低并非绝对的好坏。Self-complementarity，通常在实时应用中被提及，它描述的是某个 …

为什么Self-Attention要通过线性变换计算Q K V，背后的原理或直观 … 为什么Self-Attention要通过线性变换计算Q K V，背后的原理或直观解释是什么？最近在看self-attention和transformer，对为什么self-attention需要通过把输入向量分别乘三个矩阵作线性变换 …

综合教程第四版welearn答案 - 知乎 全新版大学进阶英语：综合教程第4版welearn Unit 03 Self Test (Unit-Based)Part III答案 Part III答案↓↓↓ 以上就是这次和大家分享的内容，觉得喜欢的可以点赞同喔，觉得有用的话可以收藏起来哦！ …

transformer中: self-attention部分是否需要进行mask？ - 知乎 关于self-attention中存在的mask情况，可以看下面的内容。同时，如果想要更好的理解Attention mask，建议先看Transformer的解码过程，参加文章：

Self Evaluation Maintenance Model

The Self-Evaluation Maintenance (SEM) Model: Protecting Your Self-Esteem Through Social Comparison

Understanding the Core Principles of SEM

Reflection and Basking in Reflected Glory (BIRGing)

Example Scenarios Illustrating SEM

Practical Implications and Managing Self-Esteem

Conclusion

FAQs

Links:

Converter Tool

Conversion Result:

Formatted Text:

Search Results: