Heisenberg Picture Example

Delving into the Heisenberg Picture: A Practical Approach to Quantum Mechanics

Quantum mechanics presents two primary formulations: the Schrödinger picture and the Heisenberg picture. While the Schrödinger picture depicts the evolution of the system's state vector over time, the Heisenberg picture focuses on the time-dependent evolution of the operators. This article aims to clarify the Heisenberg picture, explaining its core concepts, contrasting it with the Schrödinger picture, and illustrating it with practical examples. We will see how this seemingly different perspective offers equivalent yet insightful ways to understand quantum dynamics.

Understanding the Core Concepts

In the Schrödinger picture, the state vector |Ψ(t)> changes with time according to the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, while operators remain time-independent. The Heisenberg picture, conversely, holds the state vector constant in time (equal to its initial value |Ψ(0)>) while the operators evolve. This seemingly abstract shift offers a powerful perspective, especially when dealing with conserved quantities.

The crucial equation governing the time evolution of an operator Â in the Heisenberg picture is:

dÂ/dt = (i/ħ)[H, Â] + ∂Â/∂t

where:

H is the Hamiltonian of the system (representing its total energy).
ħ is the reduced Planck constant.
[H, Â] is the commutator of the Hamiltonian and the operator Â, defined as [H, Â] = HÂ - ÂH.
∂Â/∂t represents any explicit time dependence in the operator itself (independent of the Hamiltonian).

This equation reveals that the time evolution of an operator depends on its commutator with the Hamiltonian. If the operator commutes with the Hamiltonian ([H, Â] = 0), then the operator is a constant of motion (like energy, momentum, or angular momentum in certain systems).

Schrödinger vs. Heisenberg: A Comparative Glance

The key difference lies in what evolves with time. In the Schrödinger picture, the state vector evolves, describing how the system's state changes. Measurements are performed on this evolving state. In the Heisenberg picture, the state vector remains fixed at its initial value, while the operators representing physical quantities evolve. The expectation value of an observable remains the same regardless of which picture we use. This ensures both formulations offer equivalent descriptions of the quantum system. The choice of picture often depends on the specific problem and what aspect of the system is being emphasized.

Example: The Simple Harmonic Oscillator

Let's consider a one-dimensional quantum harmonic oscillator. The Hamiltonian is given by:

H = (p²/2m) + (1/2)mω²x²

where:

p is the momentum operator.
m is the mass.
ω is the angular frequency.
x is the position operator.

Using the Heisenberg equation of motion, we can find the equations of motion for x and p. The commutator [x, p] = iħ is crucial here. After calculating the commutators and solving the resulting differential equations, we obtain the time evolution of the position and momentum operators:

x(t) = x(0)cos(ωt) + (p(0)/mω)sin(ωt)
p(t) = p(0)cos(ωt) - mωx(0)sin(ωt)

These equations describe the oscillatory behaviour of the position and momentum operators in the Heisenberg picture. Notice that the initial values x(0) and p(0) remain constant.

A More Complex Example: Spin in a Magnetic Field

Consider a spin-1/2 particle in a constant magnetic field along the z-axis. The Hamiltonian is given by:

H = -μ · B = -γB Sz

where:

μ is the magnetic moment.
B is the magnetic field.
γ is the gyromagnetic ratio.
Sz is the z-component of the spin operator.

Applying the Heisenberg equation of motion, the time evolution of the spin operators can be derived. We will find that Sz is a constant of motion, as expected, since it commutes with the Hamiltonian. However, Sx and Sy will evolve in time, exhibiting precession around the z-axis.

Conclusion

The Heisenberg picture provides an alternative, yet equivalent, framework for analyzing quantum systems. By focusing on the time evolution of operators, it highlights the dynamical aspects of physical quantities and offers a particularly elegant perspective for understanding conserved quantities. While the Schrödinger picture might be intuitively easier to grasp initially, the Heisenberg picture is indispensable for more advanced quantum mechanical calculations and provides a deeper insight into the fundamental nature of quantum dynamics. Choosing the appropriate picture depends heavily on the problem at hand and the desired perspective.

FAQs

1. What is the main advantage of the Heisenberg picture over the Schrödinger picture? The Heisenberg picture is advantageous when dealing with conserved quantities, as they appear as time-independent operators. It's also useful in situations where the Hamiltonian is time-dependent, as it can simplify calculations.

2. Is the expectation value of an observable the same in both pictures? Yes, the expectation value of an observable remains identical in both the Schrödinger and Heisenberg pictures.

3. Can the Heisenberg picture be used for systems with time-dependent Hamiltonians? Yes, the Heisenberg picture can handle time-dependent Hamiltonians, although the calculations can become more complex.

4. How does the Heisenberg picture relate to quantum field theory? The Heisenberg picture forms a foundation for quantum field theory, where field operators evolve in time.

5. Are there any limitations to the Heisenberg picture? While powerful, the Heisenberg picture can be less intuitive for beginners compared to the Schrödinger picture, and dealing with complicated Hamiltonians can lead to challenging calculations.

Search Results:

什么是二维海森堡铁磁体？ - 知乎 27 Mar 2018 · 有什么特性？Cr2Ge2Te6？低维里面其实有个很重要的特性，就是一维或二维的isotropic 的Heisenberg模型在任何有限温度下都不存在长程的铁磁或反铁磁序，这就是大名鼎 …

《绝命毒师》中沃尔特为何化名海森堡？ - 知乎 共同开创量子物理学的科学家们，在政治的裹挟下分道扬镖。所以我想，《绝命毒师》海森堡的代号，可能更基于下面的原因：盟军的科学家制造出超级杀人武器，却以正义的名义长青于 …

什么是Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya Interaction？ - 知乎 感谢邀请。海森堡交换作用 (Heisenberg exchange)题主应该知道吧。为了使体系的能量最低，平庸的磁性材料通常具有铁磁性或反铁磁性，在这些材料中磁矩需成平行或反平行排列，磁矩 …

统计力学的刘维尔定理与量子力学的海森堡运动方程为什么差一个 … 而Heisenberg运动方程来自于Heisenberg绘景。 Heisenberg绘景下，量子态不含时，只有算符含时，按照上边定义的密度矩阵不随时间变化。（Heisenberg绘景下的密度矩阵长啥样还没考 …

如何看待王虹和 Joshua Zahl 在 arXiv 发布对三维挂 … 听了王虹在调和分析、齐性动力系统和数论会上的报告，大概捋清楚了证明思路。（论文用的是Shading版本的Kakeya，但是报告是Minkowski版本的，大概可以认为我们采用的Shading和 …

如何理解Heisenberg不确定性关系？ - 知乎 如何理解Heisenberg不确定性关系？我们为什么可以利用 [公式] 与 [公式] 及 [公式] 来估计粒子动量与位置的数量级？如何理解动量（位置）的标准差与动量（位置）同量级？显示全部关注 …

Dünya Forum: Werner Heisenberg / Bilim ve Nazizm kıskacınca … 12 May 2019 · Werner Karl Heisenberg, tarihteki en ünlü fizikçilerden biridir. Çoğunlukla kuantum mekaniğinin geliştirilmesi ve belirsizlik ilkesinin oluşturulmasıyla ilgili çalışmalarıyla tanınır. …

如何理解海森堡的「不确定性原理」？ - 知乎 维尔纳·海森堡（1901－1976），德国物理学家，量子力学创始人之一海森堡提出了著名的“不确定性原理”：一个运动粒子的位置和它的动量不可被同时确定。我是物理科学的民科，下面关于 …

为什么有的地方把海森堡模型叫经典自旋海森堡模型? - 知乎 3 Nov 2023 · 把 Heisenberg模型里面的自旋算符当做经典的矢量来看待，这时候就叫做经典Heisenberg模型。通过这样的处理，就可以用经典统计物理来研究体系的性质，不想解析算 …

【凝聚态物理】求一个Heisenberg model自旋链的基态？ - 知乎 【凝聚态物理】求一个Heisenberg model自旋链的基态？现有一个10个格点，开放边界，自旋1/2的自旋链，受铁磁海森堡相互作用 [公式] ，求它的基态能量是多少？最好有一个精确对角 …

Heisenberg Picture Example

Delving into the Heisenberg Picture: A Practical Approach to Quantum Mechanics

Understanding the Core Concepts

Schrödinger vs. Heisenberg: A Comparative Glance

Example: The Simple Harmonic Oscillator

A More Complex Example: Spin in a Magnetic Field

Conclusion

FAQs

Links:

Converter Tool

Conversion Result:

Formatted Text:

Search Results: