Theirselves

Theirselves: A Reflexive Pronoun's Rocky Road to Acceptance

Have you ever heard someone say, "They hurt theirselves"? A shudder might run down the spine of a grammar purist. "Theirselves" – a word that feels both intuitively right and grammatically wrong – sparks passionate debate. Is it a creeping infestation of lazy language, or a legitimate evolution of the English language struggling to keep up with modern usage? Let's dive into the surprisingly complex world of this reflexive pronoun.

The Case Against "Theirselves": Grammatical Tradition

Traditional grammar dictates that reflexive pronouns – words like "himself," "herself," "itself," etc. – must agree in number and gender with their antecedent (the noun or pronoun they refer back to). The problem with "theirselves" is its antecedent can be plural and of indeterminate gender. Since "their" already serves as the plural possessive form of "they," a reflexive form mirroring this structure – grammatically speaking – shouldn’t exist. The traditionalist argument rests on the idea that a consistent, predictable grammatical system enhances clarity and precision. To illustrate, consider the sentence: "The team injured theirselves during the game." Traditionalists would prefer "The team injured themselves," arguing that "theirselves" is redundant and grammatically incorrect. This adherence to established rules is the cornerstone of the argument against its use.

The Case For "Theirselves": Linguistic Evolution and Inclusivity

The counter-argument champions linguistic evolution and the need for inclusive language. English is a living, breathing organism, constantly adapting to societal changes. The singular "they" has been used for centuries to refer to a person of unspecified gender, and its acceptance is growing, especially in formal settings. The lack of a gender-neutral reflexive pronoun creates a gap in the language. Using "themselves" when the antecedent is plural and of mixed or unspecified gender feels awkward and sometimes inaccurate. Consider the example: "The applicants submitted their applications and reviewed theirselves thoroughly." Forcing the use of "themselves" feels jarring when the applicants are a diverse group. Advocates for "theirselves" argue that this word fills a crucial linguistic niche, promoting inclusivity and reflecting the reality of our gender-fluid world.

Usage and Context: Navigating the Grey Area

While "themselves" remains the grammatically "correct" option according to traditional rules, the tide is shifting. The usage of "theirselves" is becoming increasingly prevalent, especially in informal speech and writing. This doesn't imply a disregard for grammatical correctness, but rather a recognition of evolving linguistic norms. The acceptability of "theirselves" often depends on context and audience. In a formal academic paper, "themselves" is undoubtedly the safer choice. However, in a casual conversation or a blog post addressing a diverse audience, the use of "theirselves" might be perceived as more natural and inclusive, even if technically incorrect.

The Role of Style Guides and Dictionaries

The evolving status of "theirselves" is reflected in the way style guides and dictionaries are adapting. Some style guides remain steadfast in their rejection of "theirselves," while others acknowledge its increasing usage and offer guidance on its appropriate application. Dictionaries are also evolving; some now include "theirselves" with a note acknowledging its informal or non-standard status, highlighting the ongoing debate surrounding its legitimacy. This fluidity underscores the dynamic nature of language itself.

The Future of "Theirselves": A Pronoun's Uncertain Destiny

The debate surrounding "theirselves" is far from over. It reflects a broader discussion about linguistic prescriptivism versus descriptivism – whether we should impose strict grammatical rules or acknowledge and adapt to how language is actually used. The increasing acceptance of singular "they" and the growing demand for gender-neutral language suggest that "theirselves" may eventually gain wider acceptance, becoming a standard part of the English lexicon. However, the path to full acceptance remains uncertain, highlighting the ever-evolving and sometimes contradictory nature of language.

Expert-Level FAQs:

1. Is "theirselves" ever grammatically correct? No, according to traditional grammar rules, "theirselves" is not grammatically correct. However, its usage is increasing and its grammatical status is evolving.

2. How can I avoid using "theirselves" in formal writing? Use "themselves" consistently, even if the antecedent is plural and of indeterminate gender. This maintains grammatical consistency and avoids potential criticism.

3. Does the acceptance of singular "they" influence the debate around "theirselves"? Absolutely. The increasing acceptance of singular "they" strengthens the argument for a gender-neutral reflexive pronoun, highlighting the need for "theirselves" to fill the grammatical gap.

4. What is the role of corpus linguistics in understanding "theirselves"? Corpus linguistics, which analyzes large samples of language use, provides valuable data on the frequency and contexts in which "theirselves" appears, offering insights into its evolving usage and acceptance.

5. Will "theirselves" ever be considered standard English? This remains uncertain. Its eventual acceptance will depend on several factors, including the continued evolution of linguistic norms, the influence of style guides, and the ongoing debate surrounding inclusive language.

Search Results:

为什么是himself, themselves而不是hisself, theirselves？ 为什么是himself, themselves而不是hisself, theirselves？反身代词中，myself, yourself, ourselves, herself都是形容词性物主代词+self，而himself, themsel… 显示全部关注者 4

"them", "themselves," or "their selves"? - English Language I don't think this question is a duplicate of the one asking why themselves isn't theirselves, in part because their selves doesn't mean the same thing as theirselves. An Ngram graph for "their …

Does "They themselves" need commas? - English Language 25 Mar 2015 · Which of the following sentences has correct comma usage? a) They themselves can state their feelings. b) They themselves, can state their feelings. c) They, themselves, can …

Themself, themselves, theirself, or theirselves - WordReference … 21 Apr 2011 · I'm having problems deciding on whether I should use themself, themselves, theirself, or theirselves. So I need to know which one is correct. Also, I need to know whether …

word choice - English Language & Usage Stack Exchange 24 Feb 2015 · Instead of referring repeatedly to some male or female subject pronoun, you can use they/themselves to avoid emphasizing one gender or overloading the text with he/she, …

Theirselves - WordReference Forums 12 Nov 2007 · I've been taught that theirselves is commonly used by people who know no better. Themselves is correct. A teacher of English advised you to use theirselves? By the way, do …

Theirselves - WordReference Forums 12 Nov 2007 · Theirselves and themself for themselves are limited to Vulgar English speech or imitations of it; both are shibboleths. Themself can also occur as an unfortunate result of trying …

introduce theirselves - WordReference Forums 2 Mar 2011 · Hi to everyone.. I have a doubt on how to use themselves or theirself/themself.. Example: Students will be able to introduce theirselves at the end of the english class. Thank …

grammatical number - Why "themselves" and "himself" - English … Why, if all other forms are formed from [posessive] + self (see note), is it himself and themselves. I believe I remember being told in one of my linguistics classes that hisself and theirselves were …

“他们自己”为什么是themselves？为什么不是theirselves？ - 知乎 18 Aug 2019 · “他们自己”为什么是themselves？为什么不是theirselves？ “我自己”是myself，“你自己”是yourself，“他们自己”为什么是themselves？为什么不是theirselves？同理还有himse… …

Theirselves

Theirselves: A Reflexive Pronoun's Rocky Road to Acceptance

The Case Against "Theirselves": Grammatical Tradition

The Case For "Theirselves": Linguistic Evolution and Inclusivity

Usage and Context: Navigating the Grey Area

The Role of Style Guides and Dictionaries

The Future of "Theirselves": A Pronoun's Uncertain Destiny

Expert-Level FAQs:

Links:

Converter Tool

Conversion Result:

Formatted Text:

Search Results: