quickconverts.org
☰

Positive Murphy Sign

Image related to positive-murphy-sign

Decoding the Positive Murphy's Sign: A Comprehensive Guide for Healthcare Professionals



Murphy's sign, a clinical indicator of acute cholecystitis (gallbladder inflammation), holds significant importance in the field of gastroenterology. Its accurate assessment is crucial for timely diagnosis and appropriate management of this potentially serious condition. However, the interpretation of a positive Murphy's sign can be challenging, particularly in cases with atypical presentations or co-morbidities. This article aims to address common questions and challenges associated with understanding and applying Murphy's sign in clinical practice.


I. Understanding the Mechanism of Murphy's Sign



Murphy's sign is elicited by palpating the right subcostal area, just below the liver edge, while the patient takes a deep breath. A positive sign is indicated by a sharp inspiratory arrest (cessation of breathing) due to pain caused by the inflamed gallbladder contacting the examiner's fingers. This pain arises because the inflamed gallbladder is acutely tender and its distension during inspiration exacerbates the inflammation, causing intense pain. The mechanism lies in the close anatomical relationship between the gallbladder, liver, and abdominal wall. Deep inspiration causes the gallbladder to descend, pushing it against the examiner's fingers, triggering the pain response.


II. Performing the Murphy's Sign Examination: A Step-by-Step Guide



Accurate execution of the Murphy's sign test is crucial for obtaining reliable results. Here's a step-by-step approach:

1. Patient Positioning: The patient should be lying supine with their right arm either behind their head or at their side. This position allows for optimal access to the right subcostal area.

2. Palpation Technique: The examiner places their right hand gently but firmly under the patient's right subcostal margin, at the point where the gallbladder is typically located (the intersection of the right costal margin and the lateral border of the rectus abdominis muscle). The fingers should be positioned perpendicular to the costal margin.

3. Deep Inspiration: The patient is then instructed to take a slow, deep breath.

4. Observation and Interpretation: A positive Murphy's sign is indicated by the patient abruptly ceasing their inspiration due to sharp pain at the moment the gallbladder descends and contacts the examiner's fingers. The pain is typically localized and intense. Absence of pain during inspiration indicates a negative Murphy's sign.

5. Documentation: Clearly document whether the Murphy's sign was positive or negative and any accompanying observations like the intensity of pain, location, and patient's description of the pain.

III. Challenges and Limitations in Interpreting Murphy's Sign



Despite its clinical importance, Murphy's sign is not without limitations:

Obesity: In obese patients, it can be difficult to palpate the gallbladder accurately, potentially leading to false-negative results. The thick subcutaneous fat layer may obscure the gallbladder's palpation.

Muscular Guarding: Significant abdominal muscle guarding due to pain or other reasons can hinder accurate palpation and lead to an inaccurate interpretation.

Atypical Presentations: In some cases, the gallbladder inflammation may be less severe, leading to a weakly positive or absent Murphy's sign, even with acute cholecystitis.

Co-morbidities: Other abdominal pathologies, such as appendicitis, pancreatitis, or hepatic abscess, can mimic a positive Murphy's sign, causing confusion in diagnosis.

Subjective Interpretation: The intensity of pain and the patient's reaction can vary, making the interpretation somewhat subjective. Experience and clinical judgement are crucial.


IV. Addressing Challenges: Strategies for Improved Accuracy



To improve the accuracy of Murphy's sign assessment, consider the following strategies:

Careful palpation: Avoid aggressive palpation; gentle pressure is usually sufficient to elicit the response.

Consider alternative methods: In cases of obesity or severe muscle guarding, ultrasound or other imaging techniques should be employed for confirmation.

Comprehensive clinical evaluation: Murphy's sign should not be the sole determinant in diagnosing acute cholecystitis. It should be considered alongside other clinical findings, such as history (fever, nausea, vomiting, right upper quadrant pain), physical examination findings (fever, tachycardia, jaundice), and laboratory investigations.

Experienced examiner: The skill and experience of the examiner significantly impact the accuracy of the test.


V. Summary



Murphy's sign serves as a valuable clinical tool in assessing patients suspected of having acute cholecystitis. However, it’s crucial to understand its limitations and interpret it cautiously within the context of the patient's complete clinical presentation. Combining Murphy's sign with other diagnostic methods, such as ultrasound and laboratory tests, provides a more comprehensive and accurate diagnosis.


FAQs:



1. Can a negative Murphy's sign rule out acute cholecystitis? No, a negative Murphy's sign does not definitively rule out acute cholecystitis. Other diagnostic tools are necessary for confirmation.

2. What other signs and symptoms support a diagnosis of acute cholecystitis? Fever, nausea, vomiting, right upper quadrant pain radiating to the right shoulder or back, positive Boas' sign (referred pain to the right scapula), and leukocytosis (increased white blood cell count) are common supporting features.

3. Is Murphy's sign more reliable in certain patient groups? The reliability of Murphy's sign is higher in patients with uncomplicated acute cholecystitis and without significant obesity or abdominal muscle guarding.

4. What is the role of ultrasound in diagnosing acute cholecystitis? Ultrasound is the primary imaging modality for diagnosing acute cholecystitis, visualizing gallstones and gallbladder wall thickening.

5. What are the treatment options for acute cholecystitis? Treatment typically involves cholecystectomy (surgical removal of the gallbladder) either laparoscopically or open. In some cases, initial conservative management (pain control, intravenous fluids, antibiotics) may be employed before surgery.

Links:

Converter Tool

Conversion Result:

=

Note: Conversion is based on the latest values and formulas.

Formatted Text:

27 celsius to fahrenheit
hoover dam employment
is sung a word
star stable virus
national flower of england
sixty five number
12 different colors
management information system exam questions and answers
what space movie came out in 1992
nez perce language translation
beginning of ww2
que es un leon
where were most concentration camps located
brush border function
cross product is zero

Search Results:

Assessment | Diagnosis | Cholecystitis - acute | CKS | NICE A positive Murphy's sign has a specificity of 79–96% for acute cholecystitis [Miura, 2013; Yokoe, 2018]. However, there are limitations to its use: It is particularly unreliable in older adults and …

Murphy’s sign • LITFL • Medical Eponym Library 16 Sep 2023 · Murphy’s sign is elicited in patients with acute cholecystitis by asking the patient to take in and hold a deep breath while palpating the right subcostal area. If pain occurs on …

Murphy's sign - Wikipedia In medicine, Murphy's sign (also known as Sweeney’s sign) is a maneuver during a physical examination as part of the abdominal examination. [1] It is useful for differentiating pain in the …

Murphys Sign - Physiopedia Murphy’s sign is performed by palpating the subcostal region during inspiration. If pain is elicited and the patient suddenly stops their inspiratory effort. If pain occurs when the inflamed …

Murphy’s Sign - e Medical Updates 8 Feb 2018 · What is a Positive Murphy’s sign? When the manoeuvre is done in a patient with abdominal pain in the right upper quadrant, and the test elicits tenderness or sudden pain at …

Biliary Colic and Cholecystitis - TeachMeSurgery 26 Dec 2021 · Murphy’s sign is positive when there is a halt in inspiration due to pain, indicating an inflamed gallbladder. This can be achieved more accurately with an ultrasound, namely the …

Murphy's sign – GPnotebook A positive Murphy's sign is seen in acute cholecystitis: refers to where the patient stops breathing due to pain when an examiner touches the inflamed gallbladder; elicited by firmly placing a …

Murphy's Sign - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics Murphy's sign is the inspiratory arrest that occurs upon palpation of the right upper quadrant during a deep breath. Fever makes the diagnosis of acute cholecystitis much more likely than …

Physical Exam : Murphy’s Sign – My Endo Consult A positive Murphy's sign occurs when the patient experiences pain or tenderness severe enough to cause an abrupt halt in inspiration, usually toward the end of the breath. This suggests …

Murphy's sign: Definition, uses, and process - Medical News Today 4 Jun 2024 · A positive Murphy’s sign means that a person feels pain in their gallbladder when the organ contacts the healthcare professional’s hand during a breath. It implies that the...