Hart Doing A Literature Review

The Hart of the Matter: Mastering the Literature Review for Legal Scholarship

The literature review, a cornerstone of any academic endeavor, holds a particularly crucial position in legal scholarship. For aspiring legal scholars, understanding how to conduct a thorough and impactful literature review is paramount. This article will explore the process of crafting a compelling literature review, specifically focusing on the principles advocated by renowned legal scholar HLA Hart, whose work emphasizes the importance of conceptual clarity and systematic analysis. We will delve into the stages involved, from defining the research question to synthesizing findings, highlighting practical strategies to ensure a rigorous and insightful contribution to the field.

1. Defining the Research Question and Scope: A Hartian Approach

Before embarking on a literature review, a precise research question is essential. This stage mirrors Hart's emphasis on clear conceptual analysis. A poorly defined question leads to a scattered and unfocused review. For instance, instead of a broad question like "What is the impact of social media on law?", a more focused question, informed by Hart's emphasis on precision, might be: "How does the use of social media evidence impact admissibility standards in defamation cases within English common law?" Defining the scope – the specific legal jurisdiction, time period, and types of sources – ensures manageable parameters for your review.

2. Identifying and Selecting Relevant Sources: Beyond Case Law

Hart's work emphasizes the importance of considering multiple perspectives. Therefore, a comprehensive literature review transcends a simple compilation of case law. It should include:

Primary Sources: Case law, statutes, constitutional provisions directly related to the research question are fundamental. For example, in analyzing the impact of social media on defamation, relevant case law establishing precedents on online defamation would be crucial.
Secondary Sources: Scholarly articles, books, and legal commentaries offer diverse interpretations and analyses. These sources provide context, different theoretical frameworks, and contrasting viewpoints crucial for a robust review.
Grey Literature: Government reports, policy documents, and even reputable online resources can provide invaluable supplementary data. For example, a report on social media usage statistics might enrich an analysis of its impact on defamation law.

Selecting sources demands critical evaluation. Use keywords relevant to your refined research question to search legal databases like Westlaw, LexisNexis, and HeinOnline. Carefully assess the credibility, relevance, and methodological rigor of each source.

3. Organizing and Synthesizing the Literature: Building a Coherent Narrative

Once sources are collected, organizing them is critical. Hart’s focus on systematic thought informs this stage. A chronological approach may be suitable for tracing the evolution of legal doctrine. A thematic approach, grouping sources based on shared concepts or arguments, is often more effective for complex topics. For instance, a review analyzing the impact of social media on defamation could be structured thematically, examining issues like jurisdiction, freedom of speech, and the burden of proof separately.

Synthesizing involves more than just summarizing individual sources. It requires critically comparing and contrasting different viewpoints, identifying gaps in the literature, and formulating your own analysis. This process involves identifying recurring themes, contrasting arguments, and highlighting areas of consensus and disagreement. Remember, your literature review is not a mere list of summaries; it's a critical engagement with existing scholarship.

4. Identifying Gaps and Research Contributions: Addressing the Unanswered Questions

A strong literature review identifies gaps in existing scholarship. This highlights the unique contribution of your own research. By examining the existing literature critically, you can pinpoint unanswered questions, inconsistencies, or limitations in previous research that your work addresses. For example, your research might focus on a specific aspect of social media and defamation law that has been under-examined, providing a novel contribution to the field. This is where your research question truly comes into its own, guiding you toward identifying these gaps and proposing a solution or alternative perspective.

5. Writing the Literature Review: Clarity and Precision are Key

Finally, the writing process must reflect Hart's emphasis on clarity and precision. Your review should be logically structured, with a clear introduction stating the scope and purpose, a body systematically presenting and analyzing the literature, and a conclusion summarizing your findings and highlighting gaps or research opportunities. Accurate citations and a consistent referencing style are essential to maintain academic integrity. The language should be precise and avoid ambiguity, reflecting Hart's focus on conceptual clarity.

Conclusion

Conducting a strong literature review requires meticulous planning, critical analysis, and systematic organization. By applying the principles of conceptual clarity and systematic analysis, as advocated by HLA Hart, legal scholars can produce compelling and insightful reviews that contribute significantly to their field. The ability to identify gaps in the literature and propose original research questions is a key skill for success in legal academia.

FAQs

1. How many sources are needed for a good literature review? The number of sources isn't as important as the quality and relevance. Aim for a sufficient number to provide a comprehensive overview of the field, but prioritize depth over breadth.

2. Can I include my own opinions in a literature review? Yes, but carefully distinguish between your interpretations and the views of the authors you cite. Your analysis and synthesis should be clearly articulated.

3. What if I can't find enough sources on my topic? This suggests your research question may be too narrow or the topic might require further refinement. Broaden your search terms, consider related areas, or revise your research question.

4. How do I avoid plagiarism? Always accurately cite and reference all sources using a consistent style guide (e.g., Bluebook). Paraphrase ideas rather than directly quoting unless the original wording is crucial.

5. How long should a literature review be? The length depends on the scope of your research project. It should be long enough to provide a thorough overview but concise enough to remain focused on your research question.

Search Results:

Doing a Literature Review: Releasing the Social Science … It sets out a number of important dimensions involved in the process of literature review and by clear signposting, diagrams, and examples will help the student to carry out her or his review...

Literature Review: Writing Up Your Literature Review 5 days ago · When analysing the literature, consider the purpose of your literature review. You need to take notes on the literature, and then analyse and interpret the content. Organise the findings of your research into key concepts or particular themes. Position your research question in the context of the literature you have read.

Doing a Literature Review - Google Books It sets out a number of important dimensions involved in the process of literature review and by clear signposting, diagrams, and examples will help the student to carry out her or his review...

Advice on Doing a Literature Review - The Xerte Project Even if little has been written about your specific topic of research, the literature review establishes how and why the gap you are filling may exist and the comparability of other studies. 1. What are the key sources? 2. What are the key concepts, theories and ideas? 3. What are the epistemological* and ontological* grounds for the discipline? 4.

Doing a Literature Review : Releasing the Research Imagination 1 Jan 2018 · In combining a critical, philosophical approach with an expertly selected body of practical examples, the Second Edition of Chris Hart′s landmark text provides both the intellectual understanding...

Structuring a literature review - Learning Lab - RMIT University By organising your literature review effectively, you'll enhance comprehension and engagement, making your work stand out. Discover how to structure your review logically, ensuring that your arguments flow smoothly, making it easy for your readers to follow your analysis. There are different ways that your information can be organised in a literature review. They include:

How to Do a Literature Review If the words literature review sound intimidating, don’t worry—I’ve got your back. We’re breaking this down science fair style, step by step, so you can ace this process with confidence. Let’s get started! Step 1: Understand Why a Literature Review Matters. Before we jump into the how, let’s talk about the why. A literature review ...

Doing a Literature Review : Releasing the Research Imagination 24 Feb 2018 · In combining a critical, philosophical approach with an expertly selected body of practical examples, the Second Edition of Chris Hart's landmark text provides both the intellectual understanding...

Doing a Literature Review: Releasing the Social Science … 1 Mar 1999 · It sets out a number of important dimensions involved in the process of literature review and by clear signposting, diagrams, and examples will help the student to carry out her or his review more systematically. Learning how to carry out a literature review has always entailed the experiential.

Doing a Literature Review: Releasing the Social Science Research ... Chris Hart offers invaluable advice on how to: search out existing knowledge on a topic; analyse arguments and ideas; map ideas, arguments and perspectives; produce a literature review; and construct a case for investigating a topic.

Doing a Literature Review By Chris Hart | New | 9781526419217 1 Feb 2018 · In combining a critical, philosophical approach with an expertly selected body of practical examples, the Second Edition of Chris Hart′s landmark text provides both the intellectual understanding and the technical skills required to produce sophisticated, robust literature reviews of the very highest standard.

Doing a Literature Review | SAGE Publications Ltd In combining a critical, philosophical approach with an expertly selected body of practical examples, the Second Edition of Chris Hart's landmark text provides both the intellectual understanding and the technical skills required to produce sophisticated, robust literature reviews of the very highest standard.

Library Guides: Systematic review guide: Home - about this guide 5 days ago · To start using the guide read through Section 1 to check if your project requires a systematic review or if another type of literature review would be more suitable. Read over the guide as a whole to ensure you are familiar with what each step of a review entails.

Doing a Literature Review: Releasing the Research Imagination (SAGE ... In combining a critical, philosophical approach with an expertly selected body of practical examples, the Second Edition of Chris Hart′s landmark text provides both the intellectual understanding and the technical skills required to produce sophisticated, robust literature reviews of the very highest standard.

Doing a Literature Review (2nd ed.) by Chris Hart (ebook) In combining a critical, philosophical approach with an expertly selected body of practical examples, the Second Edition of Chris Hart′s landmark text provides both the intellectual understanding and the technical skills required to produce sophisticated, robust literature reviews of the very highest standard.

Doing a Literature Review - Google Books 6 Nov 1998 · Chris Hart offers invaluable advice on how to: search out existing knowledge on a topic; analyse arguments and ideas; map ideas, arguments and perspectives; produce a literature review; and...

Doing a Literature Review - SAGE Publications Inc In combining a critical, philosophical approach with an expertly selected body of practical examples, the Second Edition of Chris Hart's landmark text provides both the intellectual understanding and the technical skills required to produce sophisticated, robust literature reviews of the very highest standard.

Doing a Literature Review - SAGE Publications Ltd In combining a critical, philosophical approach with an expertly selected body of practical examples, the Third Edition of Chris Hart's landmark retains the strength of the original and successful previous editions, while helping researchers attain higher levels of …

Doing a Literature Review by Christopher Hart - Open Library Doing a Literature Review Releasing the Research Imagination by Christopher Hart. 4 Want to read

Doing a Literature Review : Chris Hart : 9781526419217 1 Feb 2018 · In combining a critical, philosophical approach with an expertly selected body of practical examples, the Second Edition of Chris Hart′s landmark text provides both the intellectual understanding and the technical skills required to produce sophisticated, robust literature reviews of the very highest standard.

[PDF] Doing a literature review - Semantic Scholar 1 Mar 1999 · Literature review is the search and critical appraisal of existing literature on a topic. It helps in formulating a research question after finding a knowledge gap. The research topic… This last chapter summarises the preceding seven chapters by providing questions and checklists that can be used to prepare and conduct (individual) research.

Doing a Literature Review by Chris Hart | Waterstones 1 Feb 2018 · In combining a critical, philosophical approach with an expertly selected body of practical examples, the Second Edition of Chris Hart′s landmark text provides both the intellectual understanding and the technical skills required to produce sophisticated, robust literature reviews of the very highest standard.

Doing a Literature Review: Releasing the Research Imagination (SAGE ... 27 Feb 2018 · Avoid repeating research that has already been done by Doing a Literature Review. Chris Hart defines the review and describes all the steps, always mindful of staying focused on your research goals. There are examples and helpful charts and checklists.